Check your switch break-even
Enter your balance, current rate, months left in the term, the new rate, your lender’s penalty quote and the switching fees. The calculator shows the month the savings cover the costs, if they do.
You can move your mortgage to another lender at any time, but what it costs depends almost entirely on when you do it. At the end of your term a switch is cheap and often free. Before the end of the term it means breaking a closed mortgage, and the prepayment penalty usually decides whether the lower rate is worth it. This guide covers both cases, the fees to expect, and how to work out your break-even month.
Switching at renewal
You don’t have to renew with the same lender. At maturity the term is over, so there is no prepayment penalty for leaving. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) suggests you start shopping a few months before the end of your term and not wait for the renewal letter. A federally regulated lender must send your renewal statement at least 21 days before the term ends, which is too late to start comparing.
The new lender has to approve your application and may use different criteria from your current lender. Expect to show income, a credit check and details of the property, much as you did the first time.
Does the stress test apply?
For a straight switch at renewal, usually not. OSFI does not expect lenders to apply its minimum qualifying rate (the greater of your contract rate plus 2% or 5.25%) when you move an uninsured mortgage from one federally regulated lender to another at renewal, as long as the loan amount and the amortization do not increase. That change took effect on November 21, 2024, and insured mortgage holders are exempt too. The new lender still decides whether you qualify under its own rules.
If you borrow more or stretch the amortization, it is no longer a straight switch: it is a refinance and the stress test applies. The OSFI wording covers switches at renewal, so if you move in the middle of a term, expect to qualify at the stress-test rate. See the stress test guide and the renewal guide.
Switching before the term ends
Moving a closed mortgage to another lender mid-term means paying it out early, and FCAC notes that this triggers a prepayment penalty. The penalty is usually the higher of:
- three months’ interest on what you still owe; or
- the interest rate differential (IRD), which is based on the gap between your rate and the rate the lender uses today for a term similar to the time you have left.
Lenders usually use the IRD when your rate is above current rates, which is exactly when you want to switch. Variable-rate mortgages usually carry three months’ interest only. Some lenders calculate the IRD from posted rates less your original discount, which can make it much larger than a simple estimate. Read how prepayment penalties work, estimate yours with the penalty calculator, then ask your lender for the amount in writing.
Before you break, ask your current lender what it would offer to keep you. A blend-and-extend or an early renewal can capture part of the lower rate without a penalty. Those options are covered in porting, blend-and-extend and breaking.
What a switch costs
FCAC lists these possible costs. Ask both lenders for exact amounts, and ask the new lender whether it will pay some or all of them, since many do to win the business.
| Cost | Who charges it | What to expect |
|---|---|---|
| Prepayment penalty | Current lender | Mid-term only. Often thousands of dollars. |
| Discharge fee | Current lender | Some provinces cap it. Where they don’t, FCAC says it typically ranges from no charge up to $400. |
| Assignment or transfer fee | Current lender | Some lenders charge one when you move to another lender. |
| Legal or notary fees | Lawyer or notary | FCAC says professional fees for a discharge are typically between $400 and $2,500. |
| Appraisal | New lender | Only if the new lender wants the value confirmed. |
| Registration and setup fees | New lender, land registry | Varies by lender and province. |
| Cash back repayment | Current lender | Mid-term only, if you received cash back. |
Standard charge or collateral charge
How your mortgage is registered affects how easy it is to move. FCAC describes two kinds of charge:
- A standard charge secures only the mortgage and is registered for the amount of the mortgage.
- A collateral charge can secure several loans with the same lender, such as a line of credit, and may be registered for more than the mortgage amount.
With a collateral charge, FCAC warns that you may have to pay fees to remove the existing charge and register a new one when you switch. You must also repay, or transfer to the new lender, every loan secured by that charge, including lines of credit and car loans. In practice a standard charge can often be transferred to the new lender at low cost, while a collateral charge is often discharged and registered again, with legal fees. Ask your lender, lawyer or notary which kind you have, and allow extra time if it is collateral. A readvanceable mortgage with a home equity line of credit is usually a collateral charge.
In Quebec
The same federal rules apply, and the paperwork is handled by a notary. The discharge is called a quittance, and lenders often describe moving the existing hypothec to a new lender as a transfer by subrogation. Whether your mortgage can be transferred this way or needs a new hypothec depends on both lenders, so ask the new lender and the notary before you compare costs.
Worked example: is the lower rate worth the penalty?
Maya owes $400,000 on a fixed mortgage at 5.49%, with 36 months left in the term and 22 years of amortization. Another lender offers 4.29% for three years. Her payment would fall from $2,598.83 to $2,335.25 a month, a saving of $263.58. She budgets $1,500 for legal, discharge and appraisal fees. These rates and fees are illustrations, not quotes.
| Penalty charged | Total cost with fees | Interest saved by the end of the old term | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|
| IRD: $14,400 | $15,900 | $13,877 | Never. She ends $2,023 behind. |
| Three months’ interest: $5,490 | $6,990 | $13,877 | Month 18. She ends $6,887 ahead. |
The IRD here is $400,000 × (5.49% − 4.29%) × 3 years = $14,400. It is built to recover roughly the interest the lender loses, which is why the savings never catch up: a fair IRD cancels most of the gain from a lower rate. If her lender charged only three months’ interest ($400,000 × 5.49% ÷ 12 × 3 = $5,490), as is usual on a variable rate, the interest savings would pass the costs in month 18. Counting only the lower payments, without the faster drop in her balance, it takes 27 months.
Timing matters too. With only 12 months left, the penalty would be three months’ interest of $5,490, but the interest saved before maturity would be just $4,682, less than the $6,990 total cost. Close to maturity it is usually better to hold a rate with the new lender and switch on the renewal date for free. Run your own figures in the refinance break-even calculator.
Step by step
- About four months before maturity (or as soon as you’re considering a mid-term move), get your balance, rate, maturity date and remaining amortization from your latest statement.
- Find out how your mortgage is registered and whether any other loans are secured by the same charge.
- Compare offers from other lenders or a broker over the same term. Many lenders and brokers can hold a rate for 120 days. Use the offer comparison calculator when fees or cash back differ.
- Mid-term: get the penalty in writing and ask for a payout statement. Work out the break-even before you apply.
- Ask your current lender to match. The first renewal offer is rarely the best one.
- Apply to the new lender with income documents, your mortgage statement and property tax bill. It may order an appraisal.
- Sign with the lawyer or notary, or the new lender’s closing service. The new lender pays out the old one on the switch date and the charge is transferred or replaced.
- Check the first payment, then keep the payout confirmation and the new mortgage documents.
A switch at renewal often takes a few weeks from application to funding, and longer with a collateral charge, so don’t leave it to the last weeks before maturity.
Checklist before you sign
- Is the new rate for the same type and length of term as the one you’re comparing it with?
- Have you counted every fee, and confirmed in writing which ones the new lender covers?
- Mid-term: does the break-even come well before the end of your current term?
- Do the new prepayment privileges and penalty method suit you? A low rate with a harsh penalty can cost more later.
- Is the balance and amortization unchanged, so it stays a straight switch?
- If you don’t switch, do you know what your lender will do at maturity? Some renew automatically.
Sources: FCAC, renewing your mortgage and changing lenders; FCAC, prepayment penalties; FCAC, mortgage discharge fees; FCAC, standard and collateral charges; OSFI, minimum qualifying rate and straight switches. Example figures calculated with this site’s engine; your lender’s numbers will differ.
This guide is general information, not legal or financial advice. Penalties, fees and switching policies vary by lender and province, so confirm them in writing before you sign.
Enter your balance, current rate, months left in the term, the new rate, your lender’s penalty quote and the switching fees. The calculator shows the month the savings cover the costs, if they do.
Check your switch break-even →