Compare two offers, with cash back counted
Enter the same loan amount, amortization and period for two written offers, then add each rate, fee and cash back to compare the net cost. It does not include penalties or future rate changes.
A cash back mortgage pays you a lump sum when the mortgage closes, often a percentage of the loan. It sounds like free money, but the lender usually recovers it through a higher rate or conditions you may not expect. The question to ask is not “how much cash?” but “what does the whole mortgage cost over the term I will keep it?”
The short answer: on a 5-year term, each 1% of cash back is worth about 0.21 of a percentage point of rate. If the cash back offer’s rate is higher than the best rate by more than that, the lower rate costs less. The examples below show the arithmetic.
How cash back is paid
- The cash is usually a percentage of the mortgage amount, paid after closing.
- Some lenders pay it on the closing date; others pay after a set period.
- The rate attached to the offer is often higher than the lender’s lowest rate.
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) describes cash back as an optional feature on some mortgages. It says the interest rate is usually higher if you use the feature, and that the extra interest may end up costing you more than the cash you receive.
Compare the total cost, not the headline
To compare two offers fairly, use the same loan amount, amortization and comparison period. Count the interest and fees, then subtract the cash back. A higher rate with cash back can come out ahead or behind a lower rate with no bonus, depending on the numbers.
The mortgage offer comparison calculator does this arithmetic for two written quotes. It does not include future rate changes or penalties, so check those separately.
Cash back vs lower rate: $500,000 over a 5-year term
These examples use a $500,000 mortgage, a 25-year amortization, monthly payments and a 5-year fixed term. The rates are illustrations, not quotes. The first row is a lower rate with no cash back. The net cost is the interest paid in 5 years minus the cash back.
| Offer | Monthly payment | Interest in 5 years | Cash back | Net cost | Compared with 4.29% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.29%, no cash back | $2,709 | $99,999 | $0 | $99,999 | – |
| 4.44% + 1% cash back | $2,751 | $103,587 | $5,000 | $98,587 | $1,412 less |
| 4.79% + 3% cash back | $2,849 | $111,976 | $15,000 | $96,976 | $3,024 less |
| 5.04% + 3% cash back | $2,919 | $117,980 | $15,000 | $102,980 | $2,981 more |
| 5.79% + 5% cash back | $3,137 | $136,052 | $25,000 | $111,052 | $11,053 more |
Two things stand out. First, the same 3% cash back wins at 4.79% and loses at 5.04%, so the rate gap decides the result. Second, the cash back offers have higher payments every month: $2,849 instead of $2,709 is about $139 more a month. You receive cash once and pay for it a little at a time.
A higher rate also means less of each payment goes to principal. After 5 years the balance is $437,442 at 4.29% and $442,815 at 5.04%. This difference is already counted in the interest figures above.
Break-even rate gap for cash back
The break-even gap is the extra rate at which the cash back and the extra interest are equal. If the offer’s rate is above the lower rate by less than the gap, cash back costs less. If it is above by more, the lower rate costs less. These figures are for $500,000 over 25 years, compared with 4.29%.
| Cash back | Amount | Break-even gap, 3-year term | Break-even gap, 5-year term |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1% | $5,000 | 0.34 points (4.63%) | 0.21 points (4.50%) |
| 2% | $10,000 | 0.69 points (4.98%) | 0.42 points (4.71%) |
| 3% | $15,000 | 1.03 points (5.32%) | 0.63 points (4.92%) |
| 5% | $25,000 | 1.72 points (6.01%) | 1.04 points (5.33%) |
The gap is larger on a shorter term, because you pay the higher rate for fewer years. It changes very little with the starting rate or the loan size, since the cash back is a percentage of the loan. Fees taken out of the cash back make the real gap smaller.
Conditions that cut the value
- Clawbacks: some lenders require you to repay some or all of the cash back if you break the mortgage early or move your mortgage within a set period.
- Penalty structure: a cash back product may have a higher penalty, because the lender recovers the bonus through the rate or the penalty formula.
- Fees: appraisal, legal and other fees may be taken out of the cash back, reducing the net amount.
- Portability: check whether you can move the mortgage to a new home, and on what terms.
Clawback example: breaking the mortgage in year 2
FCAC says your lender may ask you to repay some or all of the cash back, and that this typically happens if you break the mortgage before the end of the term. The formula is in your mortgage contract and it varies by lender. This example is an illustration only. It takes the 4.79% offer with $15,000 cash back, which won over 5 years, and ends it after 24 months. One column assumes a pro-rated clawback for the 36 of 60 months that remain. The other assumes the lender takes back all of it.
| 4.29%, no cash back | 4.79%, pro-rated clawback | 4.79%, full clawback | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interest paid in 24 months | $41,580 | $46,449 | $46,449 |
| Cash back received | $0 | $15,000 | $15,000 |
| Cash back repaid | $0 | $9,000 | $15,000 |
| Net cost before the penalty | $41,580 | $40,449 | $46,449 |
| Compared with 4.29% | – | $1,131 less | $4,869 more |
With a full clawback, the cash back offer that saved $3,024 over the full term costs $4,869 more. The prepayment penalty is charged on top of the clawback in both cases, and it is not included here. Use the penalty calculator to estimate it.
When cash back can make sense
- You are confident you will stay in the home and the mortgage for the full term.
- The cash helps with closing costs you would otherwise pay from savings.
- The rate difference is small, and the conditions are clear and in writing.
Cash back can also make sense when the other choice is expensive debt. If you would put moving costs or furniture on a credit card, a small rate premium may cost less than the card interest. Work out both before you decide.
When to be careful
- You may sell, move or refinance within a few years.
- The rate is noticeably higher than other offers for the same term.
- The cash back is paid in a way that depends on conditions you cannot easily meet.
Can I use cash back for the down payment?
Do not plan on it. The cash is paid when the mortgage closes or later, and FCAC says the minimum down payment normally must come from your own funds. Treat cash back as money for costs after closing, and budget your closing costs from savings. See the minimum down payment guide for what counts.
Is cash back better on a variable or fixed rate?
The comparison works the same way, but with a variable rate the interest over the term is not known in advance. Compare the two offers at today’s rates, then check what happens if rates move. See fixed vs variable.
How to compare your own offers
- Get both offers in writing for the same loan amount, amortization and term.
- Ask for the net cash back after fees, and when it is paid.
- Enter both in the comparison calculator with the term you expect to keep the mortgage.
- Read the clawback clause and ask for the penalty formula.
- Repeat the comparison for a shorter period if you might move or refinance.
Questions to ask the lender
- What is the net cash after all fees and any clawback?
- What rate would I get without the cash back?
- What is the penalty if I break the mortgage in year two?
- Is there a clawback if I refinance or port the mortgage?
This guide is general information, not financial advice. Cash back programs and their conditions change, so check the written offer and ask the lender to explain every condition before you accept.
Sources: FCAC, choosing a mortgage; FCAC, down payment. All payments, interest and break-even figures were calculated with this site’s mortgage engine, using semi-annual compounding.
Enter the same loan amount, amortization and period for two written offers, then add each rate, fee and cash back to compare the net cost. It does not include penalties or future rate changes.
Compare two offers, with cash back counted →